Toronto Maple Leafs: Jonathan Bernier/James Reimer RGV Comparison
By Brian Draus
Toronto Maple Leafs: Jonathan Bernier/James Reimer – “Project Helium” Regulated Goalie Value (RGV) Comparison of Old Tandem
For my first study under the new Regulated Goalie Value (RGV), I am going to compare the old Toronto Maple Leafs goalie tandem of Jonathan Bernier/James Reimer.
Since both Jonathan Bernier and James Reimer were a controversial pair in the city of Toronto (before Reimer was dealt to San Jose), it is going to be a bit interesting to see how they score in a single game. For this study, I am going to take a bad game for each goalie over the past two seasons.
Jonathan Bernier struggled in the 2015-16 season, meaning I several samples to choose from. I decided to use statistics from the game on April 4th, 2016 where the Toronto Maple Leafs hosted the Florida Panthers.
* just a reminder, I only count goals by where they are shot from, not if they are tipped in.
More puck prose: Toronto Maple Leafs End of Year Review
The Scoring Recap (Florida Goals Only)
Click on the link to see what each variable means
(2nd Pd)
1:34: K+K2 (1-0 FLA)
10:31: F+F11 (2-0 FLA)
13:11: F+F11 (3-0 FLA)
(3rd Pd)
9:30: K+K2+K12 (4-2 FLA)
After the calculation of Bernier’s goal total, he scored 4.005, which is just barely above one per goal. I found that interesting because the Pavelec studies didn’t produce that either time.
More puck prose: Morgan Rielly: Project Helium - Regulated Plus/Minus
Now, it is time to find a game to compare Reimer to Bernier. Since he (Reimer) had a down season in 2014-15, I thought it would make sense to use that year for a study. After looking over the Maple Leafs schedule, I decided to use the Maple Leafs 5-1 loss to the Winnipeg Jets.
Here are the goals Reimer allowed versus the Jets on January 3rd, 2015.
More puck prose: NHL Mock Draft 4.5: Rounds 1-7
The Scoring Recap (Winnipeg Goals Only)
(2nd Pd)
3:29: K (1-1 Tie)
5:59: I+I1+I2 (2-1 WPG)
10:04: F+F1 (3-1 WPG)
(3rd Pd)
3:37 PPG: H+H1+N (4-1 WPG)
10:55: I+I1 (5-1 WPG)
Even though I used a game where James Reimer allowed one more goal than Bernier, he still didn’t end up with much higher of a RGV total per goal allowed. Reimer’s total was 5.047, which was slightly more than Bernier’s, however a lot of that had to do with the fact that Reimer gave up two goals from the point (variable “I”). Bernier only allowed goals from variable “F” and “K” (face-off circle and in front of the net respectively), which produces a lower outcome from RGV when it is calculated.
More from Editorials
- The problem with another expansion franchise in the NHL
- Should the NHL make referees give postgame interviews?
- Why Carolina Hurricanes fans should be excited for the 2023-24 season
- Should The Seattle Kraken Consider Trading Shane Wright?
- Why any NHL team would be lucky to add Phil Kessel to their roster
Reimer was helped however by the fact that he only allowed one goal when the game was close, due to the fact that if a goal is allowed more than halfway through the game it is penalized (if the game is tied or either team is up or down a goal).
Since this game was a blowout, Bernier got hit harder with that penalty than Reimer did (Bernier allowed two of these goals). One key that helped Reimer may have been that he allowed a power play goal, that being due to the fact that it takes away value. Had that not happened he would have had a higher score.
Next: Auston Matthews: 2016 World Championships Will Remind Us of His Skill
All in all, I think the fact that the new changes make it much more level playing field, just by looking at this one study. Given it is just a comparison of two goalies, however keep in mind that they each had areas that helped and hurt them. That is going to be a key in the future, considering the fact that goalies give up goals on odd-man rushes, etc. I think more comparison articles will be forthcoming, and maybe one of these two. Stay tuned.
Source: www.mapleleafs.nhl.com